Lead Generation Myths: Why Most Small Businesses Don’t Actually Have a Lead Problem

If your clients are throwing money at lead gen and still hearing crickets, they’re not alone.

And no—it’s probably not the platform’s fault.

The real issue? Most small business owners are following outdated, one-size-fits-all lead generation strategies that don’t match how their customers buy.

They mimic what influencers or big-budget brands are doing… in completely different markets… and then wonder why they’re not seeing results.

As a coach, it’s your job to help them stop chasing “more leads” and instead build a lead generation system that actually converts.

Let’s unpack what’s really going wrong—and how to fix it.

The Real Problem With Most Lead Generation Efforts

More traffic isn’t always the answer.

If your client’s funnel is broken, pouring more visitors into it won’t solve anything. Most “lead gen problems” are actually:

• A messaging problem – Their offer isn’t resonating with anyone

• A targeting problem – They’re casting the net way too wide

• A follow-up problem – They’re not staying in front of leads long enough to convert them

So while it feels like a traffic issue, it’s actually a conversion issue.

Let’s stop telling clients to “just get more leads”—and start helping them fix what happens after someone shows interest.

Rethink Lead Gen as a System (Not a Campaign)

Lead generation for small businesses should never be a single campaign or one-off idea.

Instead, help your clients build a repeatable, targeted system based on three things:

1. The Right Message

Generic promises like “save time and money” won’t cut it.
Your client needs messaging that hits a specific pain point or high-priority desire.

Example:
Instead of “We help you get more organized,” try:
“Never lose another sale because your CRM forgot to follow up.”

2. The Right Method

Teach them to stop copying what’s trendy—and start using what fits their audience:

• Joint ventures (JVs)

• Referral systems

• Reactivation campaigns

• Lead magnets with strong value exchange

If they’re a service-based local business, for example, Facebook ads may not be the best first move. A reactivation campaign or strategic JV could get faster, more profitable results.

3. The Right Follow-Up

This is where most businesses completely fall apart.
The average sale takes 5–12 touchpoints… but most follow up once or twice and stop.

Help your clients build trust through:

• Email nurturing

• SMS reminders

• Retargeting ads

• Personal check-ins

Follow-up is where the money is. Help them show up consistently after the lead comes in.

Want to Shortcut the Whole Process?

You could help your clients build all this manually.
Or… you could speed things up with the tool Karl built to do the heavy lifting.

The Shortcut: Profit Acceleration Software™

This coaching tool lets you:

• Pinpoint the real reason their lead gen is falling flat

• Diagnose messaging, targeting, and conversion issues

• Model smarter strategies like JVs, referral systems, or reactivation campaigns

• Build a clear roadmap to better leads, higher conversions, and bigger profits

It’s like an x-ray for lead gen—and it works for virtually every industry.

No more guessing. No more money wasted on ads that don’t convert. Just clarity and results.

Learn more about Profit Acceleration Software™ here 

Final Thoughts: Better Leads Start With a Better System

Lead generation doesn’t have to be complex or expensive.
But it does need to be strategic.

When your clients:

• Nail the message

• Pick the right method

• And follow up consistently

That’s when lead gen starts working—and their business actually grows.

And when you help them build that system?
You become the coach they can’t afford to lose.

Don’t Miss Next Week’s Weekly Win:

Why marketing isn’t an art—it’s a science.
We’ll show you how to help clients ditch the fluff and build campaigns that actually convert.

Subscribe to the Business Coaching Secrets podcast
Grab your free subscription to Six-Figure Coach Magazine for done-for-you resources, coaching strategies, and growth tools you can use right now.

Here’s to building smarter systems—and smarter clients.